Wednesday, February 12, 2025
Billericay Area Committee
Wednesday, January 15, 2025
Devolution Proposals
Local Government Reorganisation rears its ugly head once more
LGR is a tortured
subject in Basildon, where is has long been a pet project of the Labour Leader,
Gavin Callaghan, who harbours a pathological hatred of ECC – though he is far
from alone. Labour leaders always hate county councils. I could not possibly
speculate why. Although, apropos of nothing, not a single county council in
this country is run by Labour. Dissatisfaction with ECC is not, however, reserved
for Labour. I remember my colleague Phil Turner, when he was Conservative
Leader, advocating a break with ECC. There have been other advocates
on my own side, not least my old friend the late Luke Mackenzie, who long
argued passionately for unitary status for Basildon. I suspect people have been calling
for Basildon to be unitary for as long as there has been a Basildon.
Personally, I have tended to be a sceptic.
My gut instinct
is that, whatever the desirability of unitarisation, Basildon is just too
small. We do not have a big enough tax base to fund the services we would be expected
to provide – highways, looked-after children, adult social care, etcetera.
We currently have two existing unitaries in Essex – Thurrock Borough Council and
Southend-on-Sea City Council. I think both are too small and should probably never have
been made unitaries. That view seems borne out in Thurrock, where they are in a
terrible financial pickle thanks to a risky investment strategy adopted
precisely because they were pursuing additional revenue to fund services. Nevertheless,
in recent years the clamour for reform has grown increasingly noisome.
Indeed, so certain
was Councillor Callaghan that LGR was “inevitable” that in 2019, the last time he
took power in Basildon, I found myself serving on the rather presumptuously
named ‘Local Government Reorganisation and Transition Committee’. It did not
happen, of course. Then, as now, any one of a myriad of things can happen to snarl
up these cunning plans. But LGR has hung around like a bad smell, and some form
of change does now seem likely.
“LGR is a tortured subject here in Basildon, where is has long been a pet project of the Labour Leader, Gavin Callaghan, who harbours a pathological hatred of ECC”
Many of you will have
seen reports that the Labour Government has invited councils to move to a new local
government model, establishing larger, multi-area unitary councils operating
beneath combined authorities headed by directly elected regional mayors.
As I say, this is
nothing new. George Osborne advocated this years ago, and it was a pipe dream
of Boris Johnson. ECC, along with Thurrock and Southend, have been in talks to
establish a ‘Greater Essex Combined Authority’ for some time. Things
have now progressed with the White Paper and, in addition to abolishing ECC, we
could also see Basildon Council merged with one or more neighbouring
authorities to form a larger single unitary, combining many of the powers from
both councils into one. There would also be an elected ‘Mayor of Greater
Essex’, who would have further powers devolved to them by Central
Government.
ECC have now
written to the Government, requesting inclusion in the ‘Priority Programme for
devolution’. They have also, controversially, requested the cancellation of
this year’s county elections, currently scheduled for May. The decision now sits
with the Secretary of State, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, who is
expected to give a yay or nay later this month.
The timescale for
all of this is, of course, appallingly cynical, with the White Paper unveiled before
Christmas alongside changes to the National Planning Policy Framework and the announcement
of the Local Government Finance Settlement. It could not be more obviously
calculated to avoid scrutiny and push through sweeping changes.
Cancelling
Democracy
I will be clear. I am wholly opposed to the cancellation of the county elections
in May. I listened to the debate at County Hall and, while I accept the
strength of some of the arguments for cancelling them – not least the
cost of holding elections to an authority that looks poised to be abolished - I
simply do not believe it is justified. It will take years to set up a new
combined authority to replace ECC and will mean the current crop of county
councillors serving far beyond the expiration of their mandates.
I do not believe that is acceptable and I believe Conservative colleagues at
County Hall have been somewhat bamboozled, and are playing into the hands of Labour,
who are desperate to avoid local elections in the face of their party’s
increasingly stark unpopularity.
“I will be clear. I am wholly opposed to the cancellation of the county elections in May.”
In terms of next
steps, I shall be watching developments closely. I concede LGR is far from
‘sexy’, and may not grab the interest of everyone, but our services directly
impact your everyday life, from bin collections, street cleaning and highways,
to SEN provision, schools and social care. I would encourage everyone to pay
close attention to, and engage with, the discussions that will now take place
in the coming weeks and months.
Allow me to dwell on the past, for a moment…
As your borough
councillor, I naturally have mixed emotions about the prospect of Basildon
Council ceasing to exist. The Council, in its current form, was created in 1974
as ‘Basildon District Council’ (achieving borough status in 2010). Prior to
that, the Basildon Urban District Council had existed since 1955, when it was
created out of the old Billericay Urban District, reflecting the growth
of Basildon since the creation of the New Town in 1949. The Urban District had
itself been created in 1934 out of the Billericay Rural District, a far
larger district created in 1894, when local government was in its infancy, and
covering an area that included much of what is today Brentwood and Chelmsford.
I have now sat on
the Council for coming on 12 years, since the residents of Billericay East did
me the great honour of voting for me to represent their interests in the 2013 by-election.
They have subsequently re-elected me four times, which remains one of the
proudest achievements and humbling privileges of my life. It does, however, still
make me a relative ‘newbie’ in the context of the life and history of our borough.
“As your borough councillor, I naturally have mixed emotions about the prospect of Basildon Council ceasing to exist.”
Likewise, the
abolition of ECC would end that body’s 136-year history, it having been created
under the Local Government Act (1888). ECC is a body onto which I have
pursued no less than three thwarted attempts to get elected over the past
decade, most recently in 2021 (when I came within a couple of hundred votes of
winning a seat). Ironically, the Boundary Commission only just completed a review
of new county divisions, which are due to be contested for the first time this
year. I had been contemplating a fourth run but that whole exercise may turn out
to have been a colossal waste of time, and my long-standing ambition to go to County
Hall shall remain unfulfilled.
Looking to the
future
Personally, I have
always been open-minded about an Essex Mayor. Go big or go home. Devolution is
not worth doing if you do not go for the elected mayor and get the full raft of
additional powers only available to a mayoral authority. It is not worth doing without the mayor. We have seen what can
be achieved by the likes of Sir Andy Street in the West Midlands and Lord
Houchen in the Tees Valley, but I think I would probably have preferred greater
powers for existing borough and district councils than full, very disruptive LGR.
That is, however, not the direction Labour is taking us.
As a ‘small state’
Conservative, I am inherently suspicious of these proposed 'super-unitary'
councils, which I fear will be expensive to set up and take local
decision-making further away from the people they are supposed to serve. But the
Government wants larger councils of around 500,000 residents, and there seems
little opportunity to change that.
I should stress, whatever
my misgivings, it can hardly be said I have been an unalloyed admirer of the
current two-tier arrangement. Too often residents are left confused over which
council does what. I have had many first-hand experiences of these frustrations
myself, as I am sure many of you have. Frequently, services have too much
overlap, which, creates inefficiencies, while others are disjointed, leading to
poor outcomes. I also believe for some services, specifically education, SEN,
and adult and child social care, ECC is too large to provide a truly localised
strategy to support the specific needs of our communities.
“I think it would make more sense to create a single ‘South Essex’ unitary, but I also feel increasingly strongly that Billericay should not be included.”
Whilst we
currently have no idea what a future unitary council that includes Basildon
Borough might look like, the consolidation of responsibility at a more local
level could be for the better for Billericay, and Basildon Borough as a whole.
I will be examining proposals for a single unitary authority most carefully.
Basildon Labour have
made clear they want to combine with Thurrock to form a new 'South-West
Essex Council' (or, as I call it, “Basrock”), which I frankly think is
bonkers. Meanwhile, their plan would see Castle Point, Rochford and Southend
form a new ‘South-East Essex Council’. I do not believe this will find favour
with the Government, as they have specified unitaries with populations of
around 500K. ‘Basrock’ would be around 360,000, as would ‘S-E Essex’.
I think it would make more sense to create a single ‘South Essex’ unitary, but I also feel increasingly strongly that Billericay should not be included. Instead, I think we should take the opportunity of LGR to finally remove Billericay from Basildon Borough, and go in with Brentwood, Chelmsford and Maldon into the proposed ‘Mid-Essex Council’ – what I am calling “Billerexit”.
This would essentially take
us back to something akin to the old Billericay districts of nearly a century
ago, and to our suburban semi-rural roots.
Billerexit
I do not believe the
best interests of either Billericay or Basildon are really served by lumping us
together, as we have been for the past 70-odd years. The
differences and disparities between our communities have widened increasingly
over the decades and are now enormous. All the Borough’s statistics are
completely warped by the fact you have an area with pockets of serious poverty
and deprivation tethered to an area north of the A127 that is relatively wealthy and socially mobile. It completely skews perceptions about both,
particularly when it comes to accessing funding and support.
If you consider,
on paper, Basildon is one of the most affluent places in Essex, with an average
income of somewhere in the region of £36,500. However, that average is for the
borough, not the town. The higher incomes enjoyed by residents in Billericay
and Wickford obscure the fact that there are parts of Basildon with net incomes
that barely exceed £20,000. This clearly disadvantages the New Town and its
residents, as the Borough is not being prioritised for support as it should be.
“[M]y years as a Billericay councillor on Basildon Council have certainly been an eye-opener, marred by Billericay’s position as a sort of ‘whipping boy’ for many people in the New Town, thanks to persistent myths spread by Labour and the Independents.”
I have always
hitherto been a staunch defender of Basildon Borough and bought into the ‘One
Borough’ philosophy espoused by successive Basildon Tory leaders. Indeed, I was born in Basildon Hospital and, when I was a lad at Billericay
School, many of my friends were from Basildon. I have lived and worked in
Basildon my entire life. Up until quite recently, the proportion of my life
spent living in Billericay and that spent living south of the Arterial was
about fifty-fifty. Over the years, I lived in Laindon, in a flat in Basildon Town
Centre, in Vange, in Langdon Hills. I feel very much a genuine ‘child
of the Borough’, deeply rooted in communities both sides of the ‘127. I still
feel that way, but my years as a Billericay councillor on Basildon Council have
certainly been an eye-opener, marred by Billericay’s position as a sort of
‘whipping boy’ for many people in the New Town, thanks to persistent myths
spread by Labour and the Independents.
There are
perceptions, entirely false, that ‘posh’ Billericay has been consistently ‘protected’,
and that all the money gets spent here. This is held up as the source of all
the New Town’s ills and Labour and the Indies refer to us in their literature
as the “Billericay-Tories”. To be fair, there is also a fair amount of
snobbery directed at Basildon from Billericay, which I always deprecate, albeit
on the not unreasonable grounds that our town is treated like a ‘cash cow’ by
people who will never miss an opportunity to slag us off. LGR would be a good
opportunity to cleanly sunder this largely loveless marriage. One big challenge
will be for Labour and the Indies to decide on whom to blame their failings,
once they no longer have Billericay to kick around, but I suspect the larger
challenge will be convincing them that their new super-unitary can do without
Billericay’s money (which I suspect it can’t). They loathe us, but they do
rather like our cash!
Next steps
It remains to be
seen whether Mrs Rayner will smile upon any of these plans. In any event, it
will be years before any new unitaries are set up and operational. The earliest
a new mayoral authority could be up-and-running is May 2026, which could mean
the cancellation of borough elections that year.
Not wishing to
leave anything to chance, Basildon Labour want to make sure they can dodge the
elections, so have a motion going to Full Council this week to consult on changing
the electoral cycle in Basildon from election by thirds (as it always has been
in the past) to full elections every four years. This is how desperate they are
to avoid going to the polls. They feel the need to hedge their bets by seeking
to alter the electoral cycle of a council they are simultaneously trying to
abolish.
"[T]aken together Labour’s proposals amount to a mishmash of new tiers of government, and probably tax-rises to pay for it all."
Obviously, other
than scrapping upcoming elections, the overall impact will not be felt for a
long time but taken together Labour’s proposals amount to a mishmash of new
tiers of government, and probably tax-rises to pay for it all.
I do fear this is
a recipe for taking power away from communities and making local government
less responsive to the needs of taxpayers. We must be watchful that Middle
England is not once more remorselessly squeezed with higher taxes, rural
communities given yet another kicking, and Labour’s rotten boroughs given
grubby handouts without meaningful public sector reform. This is on top of Labour’s
anti-democratic proposals to strip councillors of their powers to vote against
planning applications, and Mrs Rayner’s new top-down housing targets, which has
led to Basildon Labour’s Draft
Basildon Local Plan for 27,000 houses – 5,000 of them in the Green Belt
around Billericay.
“The interests of my residents have always come first and always will do for as long as I am a councillor.”
As your
councillor, I can only assure you that I will not take this lying down. I will
not be bullied or blackmailed into accepting a form of LGR that does not serve
you, my constituents. Unfortunately, this is always the Labour way – imposing
change by Whitehall fiat. Conservatives have always supported greater joint
working and stronger local accountability through directly elected leaders, but
there are many ways to do this, and local government should be ‘local’ to
residents and respect proud local identities.
I will do all I
can to scrutinise and stand up to Mrs Rayner’s socialist diktats. The interests
of my residents have always come first and always will do for as long as I am a
councillor.
Friday, January 10, 2025
My response to the Local Plan
Reg 18 Consultation due to close
Basildon Council's new Draft Local Plan proposes 27,000 new homes
Everyone recognises that Basildon Borough Council must positively prepare a Local Plan. It does, however, need to be the right plan – one that meets the aspirations of local people and allows our communities to grow, whilst ensuring new developments are supported by adequate infrastructure and maintains the quality of life of existing residents.
No-one will get any argument from me that we need more homes to accommodate our growing population. Even more importantly, we need homes that are affordable. As a 42-year-old man with a young family still living in rented accommodation, I am acutely aware of the frustrated aspirations of multiple generations of people in this country, for whom the dream of homeownership seems increasingly unattainable. I do not want my son to grow up in a world where only his grandparents own their own home. I am far from a ‘NIMBY’.
Indeed, most people I speak to in Billericay readily accept the need for housing. They recognise that this is a plan for the next 20 years, and are pragmatic that in a borough like ours, within the Metropolitan Green Belt, releasing some land for development may be justifiable, particularly if it is not fully meeting Green Belt policy objectives. Their concern, which I share, is that we ought to minimise the loss of irreplaceable Green Belt by robustly maximising the potential of brownfield sites. They are also not stupid. They see the Labour Government’s ‘Grey Belt’ chicanery for the intentionally subjective wooliness it is. We have already seen how this slight-of-hand policy will be used against us with the recent Laindon Road planning application, passed just this week, with Green Belt land downgraded as 'Grey Belt'.In this sense, the whole starting point of the emerging Draft Local Plan, upon which the Council is about to conclude its Regulation 18 consultation, is fundamentally wrong. We need more homes, but we simply do not need anything like as many as the 27,000-plus homes this new plan proposes. This number derives from our ‘Objectively Assessed Need’, as calculated using the ‘Standard Methodology’ outlined in the National Planning Policy Framework, recently amended under the auspices of the Deputy Prime Minister, Angela Rayner, who is also Secretary of State for Housing & Local Government. Mrs Rayner's feckless algorithm is both deaf and blind to the sustainability of our existing communities, and pumps out an unjustified housing target several orders of magnitude beyond actual local need. The target being imposed on us by the Labour Government is not remotely sustainable, and legitimate local constraints like Green Belt are simply dismissed.
Crucially, what people understand is that none of this works unless we plan for the right number of homes.
"Mrs Rayner has said 'Jump', and Gavin Callaghan and his colleagues have clicked their heels and said, 'How high?'"
The 27K homes proposed in the emerging Draft Local Plan would represent a 30% increase in the Borough’s population – potentially around 65,000 new residents. This is the equivalent of building Billericay and Wickford again. The Billericay Action Group have looked at credible data from the Office of National Statistics, and they have concluded that this is 3 or 4 times greater than realistic local housing need. Of these, approx. 17,000 will need to be built in our Green Belt – over 5,000 of them in and around Billericay. Much of this land is productive farmland – vital to our future food security.
It is clear to me that the current Labour Administration in Basildon has no intention of pushing back against these high numbers or taking on their own government, as the previous Conservative Administration intended to do. Mrs Rayner has said 'Jump', and Gavin Callaghan and his colleagues have clicked their heels and said, 'How high?' Councillor Callaghan and his Labour colleagues speak disingenuously about the 14,000 people on the Council’s housing waiting list, and the 11,000 24 to 35-year-olds who are still living at home, implying these new homes are needed for them.
The reality is that few of them will be able to afford a new-build house in this borough. If they could, they would not be applying for social housing. Not one of these 27K homes will be a Council house. Considering that a large proportion of this housing will be high-end, it is clear the excessive number is to support inward migration, not our own people. We all know that so-called ‘affordable housing’ is a misnomer. Most ‘affordable housing’ is for rent at 80% of private rental levels, while 30% is for shared ownership (part purchase), which still requires a good, typically above average, income. We already know that many people in this borough cannot afford rents any higher that 60% market rate, so even the ‘affordable housing’ is unaffordable to them."Most ‘affordable housing’ is for rent at 80% of private rental levels, while 30% is for shared ownership (part purchase), which still requires a good, typically above average, income."
Specific impact on Billericay East
Specific sites of concern to me as a ward councillor are Policy IF1 for limited infill of the Break Egg Hill plotlands area, which borders the Norsey Wood Site of Special Scientific Interest. This will harm the wildlife there. The policy map, however, reveals that the site is also far bigger than the existing plotlands. Policy H1 for 1,500 homes homes on Greens Farm Lane, adjacent to Beverley Rise, The Rising and Morris Avenue to the east, with more at the junction with Outwood Common Road at Snails Hall Farm. Between the two sites there is to be a proposed extension of the Mill Meadows Nature Reserve, which I broadly welcome. I know the Mill Meadows Society and others have been working with the developer to this aim for some time. Nonetheless, Mill Meadows is largely an ‘island’ surrounded by development on most sides. The Greens Farm Lane side is currently the largest open aspect, affording a critical wildlife corridor to the meadows. Maintaining this corridor through the proposed extension is crucial, as the developments either side would effectively close off much of the current openness. I remain concerned about the reclassification of the extension as ‘strategic open space’. The amount of land that will be afforded for this purpose is now decidedly hazy. It feels to me like one of the few community benefits outlined in any of the policy areas has been quietly downgraded.Policy AS2 (alternative site), off Potash Road, is also in my ward and an application for a development here was only relatively recently rejected by the Planning Inspectorate. In dismissing the appeal, the Inspector made it clear the rationale for a development here was unsound. Its inclusion in the Draft Local Plan is, therefore, baffling.
The 2023 Green Belt Study
Ultimately, Billericay’s Green Belt is only assessed against two of the five Purposes in the latest Report, which seriously disadvantages our town. It also represents, in just 6 short years, a near-total reversal of the findings of the 2017 Green Belt Study, with land assessed as high value, being found to have almost no value at all. I have been unable to find any other local authority in this position. Every other one I have looked at is having their Green Belt assessed against at least four of the five. This would appear to be inconsistent and drastically unsound."'...[A]ll Green Belt land is considered to make a strong contribution to Purpose 5'. All Green Belt, apart, it seems, from the Green Belt surrounding Billericay."
No more Infrastructure First
There is also scant information in the Draft Local Plan regarding provision of infrastructure and services to support these proposed developments and the people who will live in them. The infrastructure in and around Billericay is already creaking at the seams and is little better elsewhere in the Borough.We are already struggling to meet the needs of existing residents. Our schools and healthcare facilities are oversubscribed, our highway network is crumbling. These services are unlikely to cope with this scale of housebuilding without significant investment and delivery of infrastructure first. Instead, this plan caters for infrastructure provision ‘at the point of need’, meaning only once a development has been built and has people living in it may we possibly get some infrastructure (assuming developers do not find some cunning artifice by which to wriggle out of their Section 106 responsibilities in the intervening period).
Affordability
Fundamentally, the current housing crisis is an affordability crisis. Yet there is no evidence that simply building thousands more homes will do anything to make them more affordable. Most sensible economists agree that high prices and high rents are here to stay, irrespective of local plans. We all know there is little real incentive for anyone to reduce house prices. The Government, business, existing homeowners, none of them really want to see house prices fall, least of all developers. The only people who really want prices to fall are those looking to buy. Everyone else has a vested interest in keeping prices where they are and they will do nothing to jeopardise that.Conclusion
This consultation has been hopelessly inadequate. Despite being critical to the future of the entire borough, impacting every resident, the Council has pursued the laziest communications strategy conceivable. If you work for a living or are not on the Internet, there is a good chance you know nothing about this consultation. You will certainly have struggled to take part in it. The Council has relied exclusively on digital channels – mostly Facebook. I have seen few physical materials or notices. The barriers faced by the elderly or otherwise digitally excluded are considerable. The Council was sluggish in providing paper documents in the libraries. We were a third of the way through this consultation before a copy was provided in Billericay Library (only one copy available and kept behind the front desk, viewable only on request). No copy was provided even to Billericay Town Council.Nevertheless, I strongly urge anyone who has not yet done so, to respond to the consultation before it closes on Sunday (January 12th).
Wednesday, January 1, 2025
Review of 2024
A difficult year but far from an annus horribilis
As we enter 2025, I wanted to say a few words about how things went during 2024.
Every year is a mixed bag but I can think of few years that have contained more dizzying personal highs, and misery-inducing lows than 2024. It is certainly not a year I shall ever forget. On the international stage, the appalling wars in the Ukraine
and the Middle East continue unabated, while at home my party, the Conservative Party, suffered the most catastrophic General Election defeat in a generation.
Westminster
Labour won a landslide election victory in the snap election called by Rishi Sunak in July, bringing to an end 14 years of Conservative rule. It was my party's
worst electoral defeat in its long history - our largest defeat in purely numeric terms since 1761. We lost 252 parliamentary seats and saw Sir Keir Starmer walk through the famous door to 10 Downing Street as the new Prime Minister at the head of a Labour Government. Locally, our own long-serving Member of Parliament, John Baron, C.B.E., retired after 23 years service. Richard Holden, outgoing MP for North-West Durham and then Conservative Party Chairman, stood in the seat to succeed him, but won with only a rather sobering majority of just 20 votes, where John's majority had previously been over 20,000. My friend Stephen Metcalfe, formerly MP for South Basildon & East Thurrock, sadly lost his seat to a Reform candidate (who, it later turned out, had criminal convictions for assaulting his ex-partner). Closer to home
Locally, as always, Conservative councillors continued to work hard for residents. I started the year grappling with the threatened closure of the Billericay High Street Post Office, which had been based in the One Stop convenience store. Fortunately, through the good offices of John Baron, we held a number of constructive meetings with Post Office Limited and, with support of colleagues, were able to secure a new main counter service. I was pleased to see the Mayor of Basildon at the ribbon-cutting ceremony and services re-provided in the old Coleby's jewellers.
The other big issue looming over us, as it has for years, was the Local Plan. Following the decision of the Conservative Administration to withdraw the previous Submission Local Plan in 2022, the Council remained under pressure to deliver a new Local Plan. As Tories, we were girding ourselves for a fight, even with our own Government if needs be, to defend the Green Belt around Basildon Borough. We had some early successes and I was delighted in late January, when the Planning Inspectorate rejected the appeal against the Council's refusal to grant planning permission for 150 houses and a care home on Green Belt land off Potash Road. I was also able, with support from the Billericay Tree Wardens and the Norsey Wood Society, to secure the Norsey Road Woodland Order to protect the woodland within rear gardens abutting Norsey Wood. We also had Norsey Meadow designated a Local Nature Reserve, offering yet further protection.
Sadly, before we knew it, the May elections were upon us. A boundary review had taken place, altering some ward boundaries, which meant the Council had to be entirely reconstituted. It was Basildon's first 'all-in/all-out' elections in over 20 years. Both my ward colleagues - David Dadds and Stuart Sullivan - had represented Billericay East since the last 'all-out' but both retired this year. I was pleased to be joined by two new ward colleagues - Andy Barnes and Martyn Mordecai. I will confess, however, while I was pleased to be re-elected, it was particularly gratifying to top the poll, even though I was at the bottom of the ballot paper. This was my fifth election in Billericay East and I never take the result for granted. It was a humbling endorsement from my constituents, made the more poignant by the fact that I also became a father for the first time the same night (meaning I missed the election count for the first time in 14 years).
My son, William, was born on May 2nd - Polling Day, of course! He is my first child, a little brother to my stepdaughter Poppy, and the whole family are completely smitten with him. This introduction of new life came after the sadness of March, when my dear friend, Luke Mackenzie, then Mayor of Basildon, passed away at the young age of just 37, after a brief but valiant battle with cancer. Luke and I were old friends and it was he who recruited me into politics in the first place. His death was a terrible personal blow, and a great loss to the Borough.
The local election results were a disastrous foreshadowing of the General Election to come. Basildon Conservatives lost control of the Council, reduced to only 13 councillors. I have never known there be so few of us. The Tory Group is now the smallest since the late 1990s. Labour have taken up administration, backed as usual by Basildon's motley collection of 'Independents'. The national picture played its part, of course, but there is no denying the part played by our less than entirely successful changes to waste (ubiquitously known as 'bingate').
The election necessarily brought an end to my time in Cabinet. I headed the Housing portfolio for 3 years. I am extremely proud of what I and my officers achieved over that period, particularly the creation of Nevendon Place - my homelessness facility in Pitsea. The Council also ended my appointment as a trustee of the Billericay Educational Trust, so I was pleased to re-join in a personal capacity. I am adjusting to my new role in Opposition, having been appointed to the Performance Scrutiny Committee and the Standards Committee.
Labour's first act was to pension off the old Chief Executive and start restructuring the Council. They now have us borrowed up to the hilt to the tune of millions, which they ploughed into buying up real estate in Basildon. Like their Westminster counterparts, Basildon Labour are never happier than when spending other people's money. I think we shall probably need to brace ourselves for a whacking rise in Council Tax come the budget-setting in February. Goodness only knows what will happen if they are successful in merging Basildon Borough with Thurrock, as is their stated aim.
Albeit now in Opposition, Conservative councillors continue to work hard. I finally got those street lights fixed between Crown Road and Jacksons Lane. Thanks are also due to my county colleague, Cllr. Anthony Hedley (Con, Billericay & Burstead), for finally securing full resurfacing of Hillside Road, Chapel Street and Valley Road, all badly in need to investment for some time. It is also largely through his good offices, as former Cabinet Member for Business Engagement, that we have the Billericay Business Improvement District. We also saw the opening of the long-awaited new play area and skate park in Lake Meadows, along with a state-of-the-art Changing Places toilet facility. Colleagues and I are still lobbying for improvements to local bus services, as well as raising residents' concerns about the proposed National Grid pylons, and closure of South Green GP Surgery. Nothing, however, will be more important than fighting Labour's new Draft Local Plan for 27,000 homes (grossly in excess of realistic local need). The Regulation 18 consultation is due to end on January 12th.
Looking forward
I wish all of you in Billericay East, or wheresoever you may be, all the best for a very Happy, healthy and prosperous New Year.
Thursday, November 21, 2024
New Draft Local Plan
Reg 18 Consultation now open
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b53b/0b53b84fa504e9b10120112bd30a4bda93a8c782" alt=""
"...It's certainly not my plan. I don't want her rotten plan and nor do my constituents!"
"There is a housing crisis, and it is largely an affordability crisis. But there is no evidence to support the contention that simply granting permission for more homes (mostly in the irreplaceable Green Belt) will bring down house prices."
"I can think of few things in this country more entirely broken than our wholly dysfunctional planning system."
Tuesday, October 8, 2024
Conservative Leadership 2024: Post-Conference Update
MPs move towards third ballot
The remaining four candidates set out their stalls at the Party Conference in Birmingham
I did not attend the Conservative Party Conference this year
(in truth, I haven’t been in years) but this conference represented a major
milestone in the 2024 Conservative Leadership Election, as the four remaining
candidates to replace Rishi Sunak set out their respective stalls to the Party
faithful last week.
The importance of this stage of the contest can hardly be overstated.
It is not a regular feature of Tory leadership elections but the last time it
happened it was considered quite decisive. For this, one must cast one’s mind
back nearly 20 years, to the 2005 Leadership Election. David Davis entered that
contest looking like the ‘obvious successor’ to outgoing leader Michael Howard.
Then, as now, we were in Opposition and candidates were vying to become the
next Leader of the Opposition.
At the 2005 conference in Blackpool, Mr. Davis delivered his
big speech but was widely perceived to have performed poorly. I watched the speech,
and I would say it was competent but underwhelming. Meanwhile, Mr. Davis’ younger
rival, David Cameron, gave a barnstormer of a speech, delivered without notes, and
Mr. Cameron ultimately left Blackpool as the darling of Conference. It led to a
steep turnaround in their relative chances. That morning, Mr. Davis had been the
clear favourite, with Mr. Cameron trailing in third place behind Kenneth Clarke.
By that same evening, the bookies had Mr. Cameron as the odds-on frontrunner. As
we all know, Mr. Cameron went on to win the leadership and, in due course, the
2010 and 2015 general elections.
I have tagged each speaker with a link to their speech on
YouTube.
The first up on the main stage in Birmingham last week was
Shadow Security Minister Tom Tugendhat.
I would characterise the Colonel’s speech as brimming with sincerity and high purpose,
but a bit of a damp squib, in that it lacked that ‘wow’ factor he really needed
to deliver at this stage of the contest. It was a bit like one of those
fireworks, that goes up making all the right noises, only to fizzle out with an
anticlimactic ‘pop’. His relative lack of experience speaking at this level
probably showed. I anticipate that the Colonel will be the first to be
eliminated when MPs vote this week, but he can hold his head up high, having
fought a plucky rearguard action and I suspect he will feature prominently in
the Shadow Cabinet of whomever succeeds Mr. Sunak.
Next up was Shadow Home Secretary James Cleverly.
His speech is being widely touted as the break-out performance of the match.
Colonel Cleverly, who came in third place in the first two MP ballots in
September, has steadily been building momentum and delivered an assured
performance. He is probably the most experienced of the remaining four candidates,
as I outlined in my previous
blog. He also wins the prize for the best jokes, particularly a good line
about being mobilised as a reservist and assuming he would be sent to Baghdad
or Basra and being sent… to Luton. Although he arrived in Birmingham trailing
behind Mr. Jenrick and Mrs Badenoch, the Colonel left Conference with a spring
in his step and the wind in his sails and is now the bookies’ favourite to make
it into the final two with Mr. Jenrick. Colonel Cleverly actually came to
Billericay on Friday and addressed members of the Basildon & Billericay
Conservative Association and he was very impressive.
Former Immigration Minister Robert
Jenrick was the penultimate speaker, currently seen as the frontrunner
and, at 42 years of age, the youngest of the candidates. Mr. Jenrick is an
interesting guy. Formerly seen as a broadly centrist politician, he has recently
manœuvred himself to the right of the Party, shouldering past more established figures
like Suella Braverman and Dame Priti Patel. He gave a strong performance in
Birmingham, and he too put in appearance in Billericay, a week or so before
Colonel Cleverly. On both occasions, he majored on immigration and leaving the
European Convention on Human Rights. If I am being brutally honest, I worry
that Mr. Jenrick is a bit of a one-trick pony on immigration, and I cannot say
I found myself entirely convinced that leaving the ECHR is the kind of panacea
he seems to think it is. I would not say his speech was a gamechanger. He
delivered it without notes or autocue, but it did not lift the roof off Conference
like Cameron in ’05.
The final speaker was Shadow Housing Secretary Kemi Badenoch,
who is in many ways the ‘firebrand’ candidate in this contest. She gave an
uncompromisingly robust speech, centred around hard truths and the need to
renew both the Tory Party and the country. There is no denying the attractiveness
of her plain-speaking, no-nonsense attitude. My only concern remains a worry
that she is just too enmeshed in culture wars that turn off, or simply do not
interest, huge sections of the electorate. She dropped a couple of clangers at
Conference, seeming to oppose maternity pay (comments she later clarified) and
suggesting some civil servants wanted ‘locking up’. But her pitch on stage went
well and I suspect she will have been happy with how it went down in the hall.
The ball now goes back into the MPs’ court, with a further
ballot this afternoon to reduce the remaining four to three, then another
ballot tomorrow, which will give us the final two, who will be presented to the
Party membership.
I saw an analysis somewhere (apologies, I can’t remember
where, so cannot attribute) that compared the process to the ‘Sorting Hat’ in “Harry
Potter”. In this analysis, Colonel Tugendhat was ‘Ravenclaw’ for his intellect
and attention to detail. Colonel Cleverly was ‘Hufflepuff’ for his steadfastness
and Party loyalty. Mr. Jenrick was ‘Slytherin’ for his cunning and ambition.
While Mrs Badenoch was ‘Gryffindor’ for her courage and indefatigability. I
think I would broadly subscribe to that. All four candidates have great
strengths.
I shall be lobbying our local MP, Richard Holden, to support James Cleverly. We should get the results of the penultimate MPs’ ballot at 3:30 p.m. and then the final ballot ahead of the membership vote will take place tomorrow.
Thursday, August 29, 2024
Billericay Post Office latest
Light at the end of the tunnel
Andrew has continued to plug away at this with Post Office Ltd. and Basildon Council officers.
It has been a while since I posted my last update on the Billericay High Street Post Office back in March but
I can assure you all that activity has continued behind the scenes and I wanted to give residents a further update on progress so far.
Obviously, one big advent since my last update has been the General Election and I want to place on record my thanks to our former MP, John Baron, for all his efforts and for facilitating our meetings with the Post Office. I also remain indebted to Jim Sims, Head of Economic Development at Basildon Council, who has been of inestimable assistance in helping find a way forward to secure continuation of a main Post Office counter service in our High Street.
Firstly, my apologies to those who have been understandably concerned about the future of the service and frustrated by how little information I have been able to share. I hope residents will appreciate that there are commercial sensitivities until such time as Post Office Limited formally exchange contracts with any potential future postmaster and this limits what I am am able to confirm publicly until all relevant parties have officially signed on the dotted line.
I am aware that many of you have spoken to the existing Post Office staff at the One Stop, who are unaware of what is happening and what the future holds. I know this has been a matter of huge concern to many residents. It is very regrettable and I have communicated this directly to the Post Office. Unfortunately, this is out of their hands, as the existing staff are employed by One Stop, who are responsible for the information that is shared with their staff. I am assured by the Post Office that they have informed One Stop that an application is progressing to transfer the service to a new location and have suggested that they share this update with their staff but this is, ultimately, a matter for One Stop. Obviously, it is also necessarily the case that any future hiring of staff at the new Post Office will likewise be a matter for the new postmaster once they take over the role from One Stop.
I can reassure residents that Post Office Limited remains committed to maintaining a full counter service in Billericay High Street when the current branch closes in November. Having advertised the opportunity and having received a number of applications, I am happy to report that negotiations with one of the applicants is now at an advanced stage. Some of you probably think you already know where this is (I have seen speculation on the Billericay Discussion Page) and you may well be right but I am unable to confirm until contracts are signed (God forbid I should jinx it). As soon as this happens, an announcement will be made.
There are still one or two details to be ironed out but I look forward to being able to share a positive announcement very shortly and we hope to be able to secure the Mayor of Basildon to come and officially open the new Billericay High Street Post Office in due course.
This has been a lengthy collaborative process between the Post Office, Basildon Council and Billericay Town Council over the past 12-18 months, working together to try and do all we can to secure a replacement postmaster. It has been a challenging process at times, as the bureaucracy surrounding the arrangements has been out of this world. It has required the alignment of a suitable premises, with a willing and suitable postmaster, approval of both the Royal Mail and Post Office Limited, and access to capital funding (which has been appreciably constrained since the Horizon IT scandal). We are not yet at the finish line but, after periods where things looked a little touch and go, it does now appear to be heaving into view.
I will, of course, continue to provide updates as and when I can.
Billericay Area Committee
Conservatives deliver investment in Billericay A number community funding applications have been approved On Tuesday, February 11th, I atten...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8204c/8204cc603cb02955eb960dfbc049a0e3733c4a31" alt=""
-
Light at the end of the tunnel Andrew has continued to plug away at this with Post Office Ltd. and Basildon Council officers. It has been...
-
Elections are upon us. It's Local Elections time and that means my annual Runners & Riders blog Current composition of Basildon C...
-
Reg 18 Consultation due to close Basildon Council's new Draft Local Plan proposes 27,000 new homes Everyone recognises that Basildon B...